Warning:Twilight Spoilers Ahead. Well-Heeled has recently been posting about the
Twilight series. While watching the movie she was drawn to the love story between Bella and Edward because of the certainty of it. Bella makes a decision and doesn't have to ever really make one again, but after reading two of the books Well-Heeled believes that Bella lacks the character development to make the books really good. I agree with both points. How nice would it be to just have your life laid out before you, how easy. And when it comes to Bella, well I'll get to that soon.
Having read all four books I have to give Stephanie Meyer's credit. She created a really good story, and even when her writing felt rough wanting to know what happened kept me reading. That is until
Breaking Dawn.
When I started the series I didn't realize that I disliked Bella and Edward together until Jacob was really introduced in the second book. When she was with Jacob I realized she actually had a personality. Jacob soon became my favorite character and I think what kept me reading was the hope that she would leave Edward (and of course wanting to know what will happen with Jacob).
In
Breaking Dawn I actually enjoyed the first and second part of the book, especially when the story was told through his eyes. He was dealing with real angst and pain and my heart went out to him. Bella meanwhile, seemed to jump off the deep end.
The final part of the book, when Bella becomes a vampire, was a huge disappointment. Meyer's even managed to ruin Jacob for me. And Bella, awkward and out of it before, becomes too perfect.
I was left with a sadness that all she has left of her life is Edward. She is a young girl who wasn't particularly interested in anything until she met Edward, and now she is only interested in him.
Doing some google searching I came across this review in
Bitch Magazine. The article focuses on the sexual politics of the novel. After reading it I realized what bothered me so much about Bella and Edward in
Breaking Dawn:
Breaking Dawn’s Bella is a throwback to a 1950s housewife, except for the fact that Edward has turned her into a vampire. But this act is one of ’50s-esque female self-sacrifice: It’s precipitated by Bella’s need to let her human self die in order to save their half-vampire baby. Their monstrous offspring is frightening, but what’s really frightening is Bella and Edward’s honeymoon scene. Edward, lost in his own lust, “makes love” so violently to Bella that she wakes up the next morning covered in bruises, the headboard in ruins from Edward’s romp. And guess what? Bella likes it. In fact, she loves it. She even tries to hide her bruises so Edward won’t feel bad. If the abstinence message in the previous books was ever supposed to be empowering, this scene, presented early in Breaking Dawn, undoes everything.
And that is what it comes down to for me. Bella completely gives up her life and does everything she can not to let Edward know when something was wrong. For those that have read the books remember the turning into a vampire scene?
As a feminist this bothers me, as a lover of a good story I'm sad the way the series ended, and as a pf blogger I have to note that the book also reinforces the prince charming myth that a man will come in and solve all our problems. Any concerns about money Bella may have are quickly quieted by Edward's vast fortune, because of course if he is going to be her savior he will be in all ways.
All of a sudden I really miss Buffy and Angel.







